"Sure," I said, "as much as it's possible for me to love anyone, I did."
I wasn't trying to sound all mysterious and broken. And I didn't mean to sound like a tortured 14-year-old poet when I added, "But what does love mean?"
If love is just a momentary feeling, like anger or sadness or lust, then sure, there were plenty of times when I felt love for SnarkEx.
But is love more than just something you feel at a certain moment? For example, you might be angry at someone but still know that, in the bigger picture, you love them. So what does that mean? Is loving them just an acknowledgment that they're an essential part of your life, regardless how you feel at the moment? When SnarkEx told me during our breakup that she didn't love me anymore, was she telling me that I was no longer important to her?
I love tennis. I love chocolate and beer and fried cheese. I love sex. I love my cats. I love warm spring days. I love my penis. I love my family. But in each of those cases, "love" means something different. And maybe, at different times, I have felt the same kind of love for a person that I do for tennis or chocolate or warm spring days. But that's not what people expect you to mean when you tell them, "I love you."
I've found that it's way easier for me to tell my cats I love them than to say it to the humans in my life. I don't know why that is. Is it because I love cats more than people? Easier to make myself vulnerable to them? The thing is, if love is just a feeling, a surge of emotion at any given moment, then I probably do feel it more often for my cats than for people. When my cat sits on my chest and purrs and looks up at me with an expression of profound contentment, I get such a rush of emotion that it's almost enough to make me believe in God. I rarely get that feeling with people.
It's not that I never feel that surge with people. The first time I said "I love you" to each of my girlfriends, I meant it. (And not all of those times were orgasm-related.) I've always said it first, which I assume is because men are supposed to take the initiative in these situations. (When I said it to my crazy German ex-girlfriend, I followed it up with, "Well, you know, Americans say that all the time." She got angry that I was downplaying it, and a tender, seminal moment between us quickly turned into one of our frequent fights.)
SnarkEx told me she loved me probably 3-4 times a day. I reciprocated maybe half the time. Because she said it so often, it didn't give me many chances to say it first, but I did on occasion. People have different perspectives on the whole "I love you" frequency question. Some think that you cheapen it if you say it too often. Others believe that you shouldn't get complacent and no one should ever have to guess how you feel about them. I see both points and could go either way.
I haven't said the L-word to AG yet, but there have been times when I'm been overcome with enough emotion to blurt out, "You're so awesome!" (Keeping with my Meerkat/Doubt theme from yesterday, there are also times when I think, "Meh.") This is probably the longest I've ever dated someone without saying it. I don't think I feel any less love for her (at this point in the relationship) than I did with the others, I'm just much more reluctant to say it. I'm being cautious. I don't know if she's impatient to hear it, but that's a consequence of dating a damaged divorced man.









